The argument can be made that home-schooled children are more authentically socialized than children raised in a "normal" school culture, where they are isolated from the rest of the community and kept in age segregated classrooms.
Most home-schoolers don't stay shut up in their cloistered homes but have their kids out in the world interacting in a real way with people of all ages. I agree that many home-school curricula emphasize rote learning, but many follow the principle of "Teach a child biology and she can be a biologist. Teach a child to think and she can be a biologist, a lawyer or teacher." That seems very Dewey-esque.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
7 comments:
I have noticed that there are so many ways (forms?) of education that aren't really touched on, but I always figured it was because we are getting certified so the information is focused on public school.
Any schooling can be a wonderful, enriching experience for the students, but I think it all depends on the teacher. Which is a scary thought, really.
(-:
Anne, I appreciate how much you love John Dewey. I think he would like you too based on how passionate you seem about life-long learning and open your mind to everything out there. That is an admirable characteristic!
Thanks for continuing this strand of thought, Anne, and for the enhanced perspective on this matter. It might be said that Dewey points towards an ideal, in this case, regard to the nature of the interactions between student and teacher, and among the students. Surely it is often the case that little headway is made (or perhaps even desired) towards the Deweyan ideal of intentionally offering young people opportunities to practice democracy in school. In that sense, home-schooled kids may be much better off in the larger scheme of things.
Oh...you might enjoy this, Anne. Just discovered a link to the blog of the John Dewey Society. Perhaps these edubloggers would be of particular interest to you...blp
I'll add my two cents, speaking as someone who was homeschooled from 1st through 7th grades. Regarding socialization, the homeschooling families in my area would schedule get-togethers, such as having a roller skating party, during regular school others when we could have the place all to ourselves. In that sense, we did have socialization with other children of different ages.
What we did not have was socialization with "regular" kids. When I started public school in the 8th grade, my values were completely different from the others in my classes. I didn't care about the popular music they liked or they fashions they wore. I didn't have the context for some of the vocabulary they used. That really made me stand out.
On the other hand, my educational values were also different. I listened to the teachers, did all my assigned homework, volunteered to answer questions, and read ahead in the textbook--for fun! It boggled my mind that so few other students wanted to do such things. I couldn't comprehend how they could consider chatting about fingernail polish more interesting than listening to the lesson. That made no sense to me.
It also came as a shock how mean they could be to each other, making fun of fellow classmates due to their appearance or speech habits or ethnicity or any of a number of things.
It made me wonder...certainly, socializing in the context of a public school does allow for a shared culture among the students, but how much of that culture is positive and how much is negative? Is that kind of socialization in and of itself what should be important? How do the students who are on the receiving end of their classmates' jokes feel? Do they appreciate such lessons of socialization? Is socialization valuable when students socialize instead of paying attention in class?
Anne- Great point. I think that there are a lot of negative connotations that go along with being home schooled. I have friends who were home schooled who are absolutely brilliant and very social and, well, "normal." I also, however, have cousins who were home schooled and are extremely sheltered, naive, socially awkward and utterly dependent upon their parents. It is all about how you raise your kids. I think it is important for parents to be aware of the importance of socialization as a child and adolescent. The danger is when that is ignored. I am sure that your kids have nothing to worry about. :)
What has always impressed my about homeschooling is how much work it must be. I usually have to choose which battles to fight with my kids, and if I have to choose between them eating their dinner or learning mathematics, I think that math would fall through the cracks. Plus, as much as I love my kids, I need the breaks I get from them when they're at school. But I agree with you about the socialization part. I used to attend an art studio that held regular classes for homeschooled kids, and I know that parents do many group activities to enrich their kids'education. The only thing that homeschooled kids miss are the socialization aspects specific to regular schools. Middle Schools and High Schools seem to have their own culture. They're little societies within society, with their own unwritten rules about what's cool and how to socialize. I don't really care for many of these rules, but children who survive them have a chance to develop a stronger sense of identity. Is it necessary? I don't know.
I love that quote, Anne! It sums up education so beautifully...and is not as far removed as teaching men to fish.
Post a Comment